desktop/group: respect direction when moving window out of group (#13490)

hyprtester/src/tests/main/dwindle.cpp

@@ -64,16 +64,16 @@ static void test13349() {
 
     {
         auto str = getFromSocket("/activewindow");
-        EXPECT_CONTAINS(str, "at: 22,547");
+        EXPECT_CONTAINS(str, "at: 497,22");
-        EXPECT_CONTAINS(str, "size: 931,511");
+        EXPECT_CONTAINS(str, "size: 456,1036");
     }
 
     OK(getFromSocket("/dispatch movewindow r"));
 
     {
         auto str = getFromSocket("/activewindow");
-        EXPECT_CONTAINS(str, "at: 967,547");
+        EXPECT_CONTAINS(str, "at: 967,22");
-        EXPECT_CONTAINS(str, "size: 931,511");
+        EXPECT_CONTAINS(str, "size: 456,1036");
     }
 
     // clean up

hyprtester/src/tests/main/groups.cpp

@@ -201,6 +201,59 @@ static bool test() {
     NLog::log("{}Expecting 0 windows", Colors::YELLOW);
     EXPECT(Tests::windowCount(), 0);
 
+    // test movewindoworgroup: direction should be respected when extracting from group
+    NLog::log("{}Test movewindoworgroup respects direction out of group", Colors::YELLOW);
+    OK(getFromSocket("/keyword group:groupbar:enabled 0"));
+    {
+        auto kittyE = Tests::spawnKitty();
+        if (!kittyE) {
+            NLog::log("{}Error: kitty did not spawn", Colors::RED);
+            return false;
+        }
+
+        // group kitty, and new windows should be auto-grouped
+        OK(getFromSocket("/dispatch togglegroup"));
+
+        auto kittyF = Tests::spawnKitty();
+        if (!kittyF) {
+            NLog::log("{}Error: kitty did not spawn", Colors::RED);
+            return false;
+        }
+        EXPECT(Tests::windowCount(), 2);
+
+        // both windows should be grouped at the same position
+        {
+            auto str = getFromSocket("/clients");
+            EXPECT_COUNT_STRING(str, "at: 22,22", 2);
+        }
+
+        // move active window out of group to the right
+        NLog::log("{}Test movewindoworgroup r", Colors::YELLOW);
+        OK(getFromSocket("/dispatch movewindoworgroup r"));
+
+        // the group should stay at x=22, the extracted window should be to the right
+        {
+            auto str = getFromSocket("/clients");
+            EXPECT_COUNT_STRING(str, "at: 22,22", 1);
+        }
+
+        // move it back into the group
+        OK(getFromSocket("/dispatch moveintogroup l"));
+
+        // move active window out of group downward
+        NLog::log("{}Test movewindoworgroup d", Colors::YELLOW);
+        OK(getFromSocket("/dispatch movewindoworgroup d"));
+
+        // the group should stay at y=22, the extracted window should be below
+        {
+            auto str = getFromSocket("/clients");
+            EXPECT_COUNT_STRING(str, "at: 22,22", 1);
+        }
+
+        Tests::killAllWindows();
+        EXPECT(Tests::windowCount(), 0);
+    }
+
     return !ret;
 }
 

src/desktop/view/Group.cpp

@@ -120,7 +120,7 @@ void CGroup::add(PHLWINDOW w) {
     m_target->recalc();
 }
 
-void CGroup::remove(PHLWINDOW w) {
+void CGroup::remove(PHLWINDOW w, Math::eDirection dir) {
     std::optional<size_t> idx;
     for (size_t i = 0; i < m_windows.size(); ++i) {
         if (m_windows.at(i) == w) {
@@ -156,8 +156,20 @@ void CGroup::remove(PHLWINDOW w) {
         updateWindowVisibility();
 
     // do this here: otherwise the new current is hidden and workspace rules get wrong data
-    if (!REMOVING_GROUP)
+    if (!REMOVING_GROUP) {
-        w->m_target->assignToSpace(m_target->space());
+        std::optional<Vector2D> focalPoint;
+        if (dir != Math::DIRECTION_DEFAULT) {
+            const auto box = m_target->position();
+            switch (dir) {
+                case Math::DIRECTION_RIGHT: focalPoint = Vector2D(box.x + box.w, box.y + box.h / 2.0); break;
+                case Math::DIRECTION_LEFT: focalPoint = Vector2D(box.x, box.y + box.h / 2.0); break;
+                case Math::DIRECTION_DOWN: focalPoint = Vector2D(box.x + box.w / 2.0, box.y + box.h); break;
+                case Math::DIRECTION_UP: focalPoint = Vector2D(box.x + box.w / 2.0, box.y); break;
+                default: break;
+            }
+        }
+        w->m_target->assignToSpace(m_target->space(), focalPoint);
+    }
 }
 
 void CGroup::moveCurrent(bool next) {

src/desktop/view/Group.hpp

@@ -1,6 +1,7 @@
 #pragma once
 
 #include "../DesktopTypes.hpp"
+#include "../../helpers/math/Direction.hpp"
 
 #include <vector>
 
@@ -17,7 +18,7 @@ namespace Desktop::View {
         bool                             has(PHLWINDOW w) const;
 
         void                             add(PHLWINDOW w);
-        void                             remove(PHLWINDOW w);
+        void                             remove(PHLWINDOW w, Math::eDirection dir = Math::DIRECTION_DEFAULT);
         void                             moveCurrent(bool next);
         void                             setCurrent(size_t idx);
         void                             setCurrent(PHLWINDOW w);

src/layout/algorithm/tiled/dwindle/DwindleAlgorithm.cpp

@@ -184,7 +184,7 @@ void CDwindleAlgorithm::addTarget(SP<ITarget> target, bool newTarget) {
         // whether or not the override persists after opening one window
         if (*PERMANENTDIRECTIONOVERRIDE == 0)
             m_overrideDirection = Math::DIRECTION_DEFAULT;
-    } else if (*PSMARTSPLIT == 1) {
+    } else if (*PSMARTSPLIT == 1 || m_overrideFocalPoint) {
         const auto PARENT_CENTER      = NEWPARENT->box.pos() + NEWPARENT->box.size() / 2;
         const auto PARENT_PROPORTIONS = NEWPARENT->box.h / NEWPARENT->box.w;
         const auto DELTA              = MOUSECOORDS - PARENT_CENTER;

src/managers/KeybindManager.cpp

@@ -2750,7 +2750,9 @@ void CKeybindManager::moveWindowOutOfGroup(PHLWINDOW pWindow, const std::string&
 
     WP<Desktop::View::CGroup> group = pWindow->m_group;
 
-    pWindow->m_group->remove(pWindow);
+    const auto                direction = !dir.empty() ? Math::fromChar(dir[0]) : Math::DIRECTION_DEFAULT;
+
+    pWindow->m_group->remove(pWindow, direction);
 
     if (*BFOCUSREMOVEDWINDOW || !group) {
         Desktop::focusState()->fullWindowFocus(pWindow, Desktop::FOCUS_REASON_KEYBIND);